By Adams Heating & Cooling Team Published
Quick answer
In southwest Michigan, a gas furnace delivers full heat on the coldest days, a heat pump heats and cools with electricity but loses output as temperatures drop, and a dual-fuel system runs the heat pump in milder weather and switches to the furnace when it gets cold. With 6,326 heating degree days a year in Kalamazoo, the cheaper option depends on your own gas and electricity rates and each system's efficiency.
Published · Reviewed
Part of our Heat Pump Installation & Replacement guides.
What is the difference between a heat pump, a gas furnace and a dual-fuel system?
A gas furnace makes heat by burning natural gas or propane; a heat pump makes no heat at all but moves it, pulling heat out of outdoor air in winter and out of your house in summer; and a dual-fuel system pairs the two, running the heat pump in milder weather and handing off to the furnace when it gets cold. A furnace needs a separate air conditioner for summer. A heat pump is the air conditioner, running in reverse for heat.
All three use the same ductwork and the same thermostat location, so in most forced-air homes the choice is about fuel, comfort and operating cost rather than a change to the house itself.
A dual-fuel system pairs an electric heat pump with a gas furnace and switches between them based on outdoor temperature.
How does the Kalamazoo climate shape the choice?
Kalamazoo's climate puts the weight of the decision on heating. The National Weather Service's 1991–2020 normals for Kalamazoo list 6,326 heating degree days against 710 cooling degree days, and the county sits in IECC climate zone 5A, a cold, moist zone. Lake-effect snow reaches Kalamazoo County on northwest winds, which matters for outdoor units and sidewall vents alike.
That ratio means your heating fuel drives most of your annual comfort bill. It also means a heat pump here has to be chosen for winter performance first; cooling capacity is rarely the hard part.
| Factor | Heat pump (all-electric) | Gas furnace + central AC | Dual fuel |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat source | Moves outdoor heat indoors using electricity | Burns natural gas or propane | Heat pump in milder weather, furnace in colder weather |
| Cooling | Built in | Separate air conditioner | Built in (the heat pump) |
| Efficiency rating | SEER2 for cooling, HSPF2 for heating | AFUE for heating, SEER2 for the AC | HSPF2 and SEER2 for the heat pump, AFUE for the furnace |
| Federal minimum (North region) | 14.3 SEER2 and 7.5 HSPF2 for split systems | 80% AFUE furnace; 13.4 SEER2 split AC | Both sets of minimums apply |
| Operating cost driven by | Your electricity rate | Your gas or propane rate | Both rates, and where the switchover is set |
| Coldest days | Output and efficiency fall as it gets colder; backup heat often needed | Full output regardless of outdoor temperature | Furnace carries the coldest days |
| Needs a gas connection | No | Yes (or propane) | Yes (or propane) |
Kalamazoo averages about nine heating degree days for every cooling degree day, so heating fuel cost dominates the annual comfort bill.
Which one costs less to run?
Which system costs less to run depends almost entirely on your gas and electricity rates and how efficiently each system converts them into heat. There is no single answer for every house on every rate. A therm of gas contains 100,000 BTU and a kilowatt-hour of electricity contains 3,412 BTU; a furnace delivers its AFUE percentage of the gas it burns, while a heat pump delivers more heat than the electricity it uses, by an amount that shrinks as the outdoor air gets colder.
The calculator below uses your own gas price per therm and electricity price per kilowatt-hour, with Kalamazoo's 6,326 heating degree days as the default, to estimate the seasonal heating cost of each option; it has no preset utility prices.
Heating cost comparison
Use the rates on your own Consumers Energy (or Michigan Gas Utilities) bills. Nothing is pre-filled except typical equipment ratings, which you can change.
Enter your gas and electricity prices to compare.
Use the rates from your own bill; check the name on your gas bill to see which utility supplies your home. Homes without a gas main nearby usually heat with propane, which changes the math considerably.
Heating cost per delivered BTU equals the fuel price divided by the efficiency with which the system turns that fuel into heat.
What can go wrong with each option?
Each option has a typical way of disappointing people, and nearly all of them come from a mismatch between the equipment and the house rather than from the technology itself.
- All-electric heat pump without a plan for the coldest days. If a heat pump is sized for summer or chosen without cold-weather performance data, it can fall behind on the coldest nights and lean on electric backup heat. Our post on how heat pumps work in freezing temperatures covers what happens below freezing.
- Dual fuel with the wrong switchover point. Set too high, the furnace runs when the heat pump would have been cheaper; set too low, the heat pump struggles through cold snaps. The right setting depends on your rates.
- Furnace and AC that are mismatched. Adding a new AC to an old furnace's blower and coil can limit both cooling and efficiency.
- Outdoor units buried by snow. Lake-effect snow can bury an outdoor unit placed too low; heat pumps need clearance for airflow and defrost drainage.
Two regulatory points also apply. New split-system heat pumps and air conditioners use lower-GWP A2L refrigerants such as R-454B or R-32, although the EPA removed the installation deadline for systems built from pre-2025 components (91 FR 31284, effective July 27, 2026). For gas furnaces, a 95% AFUE minimum is currently scheduled for furnaces made from December 18, 2028; that rule is under litigation and a pending delay petition.
A heat pump installed in zone 5A needs a stated plan for the coldest days, either a cold-climate model, backup heat or a furnace.
Are there rebates or tax credits that change the comparison?
Utility rebates can change the comparison; the federal tax credit no longer does. The IRS states that the 25C energy-efficient home improvement credit does not apply to equipment placed in service after December 31, 2025. Utilities such as Consumers Energy may offer rebates on qualifying heating and cooling equipment; amounts change and funds are limited, so check the current program page before you buy. Our guide to HVAC and Water Heater Rebates for Kalamazoo Homeowners (2026) explains the programs in more detail.
Federal 25C tax credits are not available for HVAC equipment placed in service after December 31, 2025.
How do you decide which fits your home?
You decide by running the operating-cost math on your own rates, then checking that the equipment you are quoted can actually carry your house on the coldest nights. Dual fuel often appeals to households that want heat pump efficiency in spring and fall without giving up gas heat in January; an all-electric heat pump appeals to homes without gas service or households planning around electric rates; a furnace with central AC remains the straightforward choice where gas is inexpensive and the existing furnace setup works.
Adams Heating & Cooling is a family-owned company that has served Kalamazoo for 30+ years and is a Daikin comfort partner that installs both heat pumps and furnaces. Estimates on replacements and new installation are free (see Current Specials), and HVAC Financing through Optimus Financing is available. Our Google reviews show what homeowners say about the work. To talk through your options, request service or call (269) 349-7240.
A fair heating comparison uses the homeowner's own utility rates and the quoted equipment's published efficiency ratings.
Frequently asked questions
Can a heat pump heat a house in Kalamazoo by itself?
It can when it is chosen and sized for winter, but output and efficiency fall as outdoor temperatures drop, so an all-electric system needs a plan for the coldest nights, such as a cold-climate model or backup heat. Kalamazoo's 6,326 heating degree days make winter performance the deciding factor.
What is a dual-fuel system?
A dual-fuel system pairs an electric heat pump with a gas or propane furnace. The heat pump heats in milder weather and the furnace takes over below a switchover temperature, and the heat pump also provides summer cooling.
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace?
It depends on your gas price per therm, your electricity price per kilowatt-hour and the efficiency of each system. The calculator on this page uses your own rates and Kalamazoo's heating degree days to estimate a seasonal comparison.
What efficiency does a new heat pump need in Michigan?
In the Department of Energy's North region, which includes Michigan, a new split-system heat pump must meet at least 14.3 SEER2 and 7.5 HSPF2. A new split-system central air conditioner must meet at least 13.4 SEER2.
Will gas furnaces be banned?
No ban is in effect. Gas furnaces must meet 80% AFUE today. A 95% AFUE minimum is currently scheduled for furnaces made from December 18, 2028, and that rule is under litigation and a pending delay petition.
Is there a federal tax credit for a heat pump in 2026?
No. The IRS states that the 25C credit does not apply to equipment placed in service after December 31, 2025. Utility rebates, such as any Consumers Energy may offer, are a separate matter; check the current program page before you buy.
Sources
- National Weather Service Grand Rapids — Kalamazoo Annual Climate Report (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Pacific Northwest National Laboratory — Guide to Determining Climate Zone by County (PNNL-33270) (accessed November 19, 2026)
- National Weather Service Grand Rapids — Wind and Lake-Effect Snow (accessed November 19, 2026)
- U.S. Department of Energy — 2023 Central Air Conditioner and Heat Pump Standards FAQ (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Federal Register — Phasedown of Hydrofluorocarbons: Reconsideration of Certain Regulatory Requirements (91 FR 31284) (accessed November 19, 2026)
- U.S. EPA — Technology Transitions HFC Restrictions by Sector (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Federal Register (govinfo) — Energy Conservation Standards for Consumer Furnaces, Final Rule (88 FR 87502) (accessed November 19, 2026)
- ACCA — U.S. Supreme Court Reopens Non-Condensing Furnace Fight (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Federal Register (govinfo) — DOE Request for Comment on the Consumer Furnace Rule Delay Petition (accessed November 19, 2026)
- IRS — Energy Credit FAQs (accessed November 19, 2026)
- Consumers Energy — Heating and Cooling Rebates (accessed November 19, 2026)
